Thousand and One Island Dressing

Sherry Peyton


We decided we had to have some Reuben sandwiches,so I set out on a quest to create a thousand island dressing worthy of such a meat. I came up with what we loved.And I'll throw in the sandwich recipe for free! Hope you give it a try. If you like this recipe, see others at my website:


★★★★★ 1 vote

15 Min


  • 1 c
  • 1/4 c
    very finely minced red sweet pepper
  • 2 Tbsp
    very finely minced shallot
  • 1 Tbsp
    heaping, sweet pickle relish
  • 1 Tbsp
    heaping, finely chopped pimento olives
  • 1 Tbsp
  • 1 Tbsp
    chili sauce
  • 1 Tbsp
    fresh parsley, finely minced

How to Make Thousand and One Island Dressing


  1. Place all together in a bowl and mix well. (Note: I placed the pickle relish in a small sieve and pressed out some of the liquid). Place in fridge for a couple of hours to let the flavors meld.
  2. For a wonderful Reuben: For each sandwich: two slices Jewish rye bread. Butter once side of each and place under broiler until melted and lightly browned. Then on the untoasted side of one,slather with a TBSP or more of the 1000 Island dressing. Place about 1/3 of a pound of deli-quality corned beef on top.
  3. Take sauerkraut which has been placed in a sieve and drained and place on top, about 1/2 c on each top of the corned beef. Cover this with finely sliced good quality swiss cheese (I used Ementhaler). Place on a broiler pan. Turn off the oven from the broiling. Place the sandwiches in the oven to let the cheese melt and the meat to warm a bit. Slather the other slice of bread with more 1000 Island dressings and place on top, slice in half and enjoy.

Printable Recipe Card

About Thousand and One Island Dressing

Course/Dish: Dressings
Other Tag: Quick & Easy
Hashtags: #sandwiches #salads

Show 6 Comments & Reviews

15 Breakfast Recipes You Need in Your Recipe Box

15 Breakfast Recipes You Need in Your Recipe Box

Melt-in-your-mouth apple donuts, ooey gooey cinnamon rolls, coffee cakes bursting with blueberry and cheesy breakfast casseroles, we’re drooling for these breakfast recipes. Getting the family to wake up is hard unless you have these recipes in your arsenal. Once the delicious smells reach their noses, the whole family will come running to the kitchen. Whether […]

14 Lazy Weeknight Dinner Ideas

14 Lazy Weeknight Dinner Ideas

Having one of those “ugh, I don’t feel like cooking” kind of days? These fix it and forget it recipes are here to save the day. Super easy with minimal prep work, you won’t have to stand over a stovetop for an hour to make these weeknight meals. With little effort, you’ll have a family-approved […]

7 Tuna Casserole Recipes

7 Tuna Casserole Recipes

Since the 1950s, tuna noodle casserole has been infamously gracing dinner tables throughout the United States. Either loved or hated, this family-friendly recipe has been handed down through generations. While there is the tried-and-true version, many have “jazzed up” mom’s tuna noodle casserole recipe to make it better than ever! From the traditional tuna casserole […]