Noah's Cut-Out Sammies

Kim Biegacki


This are super easy and festive appetizer for any event. Especially for the kids and to add to any theme of party you are having. They are tasty and fun to make. You can also get the kids to help make them.

Whatever theme of party you are doing you can add these little sammies to them.

When I make some for Thanksgiving I will add a picture for those sammies as well.


★★★★★ 2 votes

as many as you want
15 Min
No-Cook or Other


  • 1
    loaf sandwich bread
  • 1/2 c
    peanut butter
  • 1/2 c
  • ·
    meats & cheeses if you desire instead
  • 1 Tbsp
  • 1
    cookie cut outs that are two sided

  • 4 slice
  • 4 slice
  • 4 slice
  • 2
    pat of butter to fry the sammies in

  • 2 Tbsp
    peanut butter
  • 2 tsp
    strawberry jam
  • 2 tsp
    chocolate sauce or nutella would be great too
  • 1 medium
    banana, sliced thin...would be great to add to this

How to Make Noah's Cut-Out Sammies


  1. These sammies just have peanut butter in the middle and raisins for the eyes. You could make any kind of sammie you want. Just use the cookie cutter side of the outline to do the bottom and top of the sammie. Top part of sammie has the details of the face on it and you will use it after you cut out the outline part.

    I will probably do pumpkins for Thanksgiving, turkeys or something else.
  2. Pair them up with something else on a tray to add interest. This was a very healthy tray of goodies. The other item is a quartered apple with peanut butter and candy corns or you can use mini marshmallows too. In the middle of the tray is popcorn.

    This recipe was my inspiration:Apple Bites

    Just didn't have the right kind of almonds or else I would have done them.
  3. These sammies were made for my nephew Brendan who is 9 yrs old and LUVS grilled cheese and he loves bacon too. So, I grilled him bacon and cheese heart sammies for Valentine's Day!
  4. These sammies are for my nephew Noah who is 8 yrs old and doesn't like anything toasted and when he eats peanut butter and jelly they must be on separate slices of bread. LOL...So, he had two larger hearts with peanut butter and the smaller hearts I triple layered the bread and had strawberry jam and some homemade chocolate sauce for Valentine's Day. This was a bit of a challenge for him but because he was so excited to have a special meal made just for him he did eat them. He took off the icing on top and ate it first and then proceeded to eat his sammies. He did not eat the little sprinkles I put on them and he was lookin' unsure when he tried the triple layer strawberry and chocolate but he ate it, so that was great!

Printable Recipe Card

About Noah's Cut-Out Sammies

Main Ingredient: Bread
Regional Style: American
Dietary Needs: Vegetarian
Other Tags: Quick & Easy, For Kids, Healthy

Show 13 Comments & Reviews

8 Cranberry Recipes Popping With Flavor

8 Cranberry Recipes Popping With Flavor

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

Cranberries aren't just for sauce anymore. We've found 8 cranberry recipes that shine a spotlight on this tart treat.

16 Avocado Recipes You'll Absolutely Love

16 Avocado Recipes You'll Absolutely Love

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

No, we can't get enough avocado either. That's why we are sharing some of our favorite recipes that feature your one true love, the avocado. You're welcome.

Pinch Tips: How To Wash Fruits & Vegetables Recipe

pinch tips: How to Wash Fruits & Vegetables

Kitchen Crew @JustaPinch

The Just A Pinch Test Kitchen shows how to wash fruits and veggies.