Gayle Seidelman Recipe

Jane's Baked Macaroni and Cheese

By Gayle Seidelman rodeomum

Recipe Rating:
 21 Ratings
Cook Time:

Gayle's Story

This is my mother in law's recipe. She's from KY where Mac and Cheese is considered a staple on the kitchen table. It's custard style so that when cooled can be cut into squares. It's hers and now my most requested dish for potlucks. So easy with only 4 ingredients. Hope you enjoy it!


4 1/2 c
32 oz
block sharp cheddar cheese cut into chunks
16 oz
cooked macaroni
salt and pepper to taste

Directions Step-By-Step

Cook macaroni according to directions. Drain and set aside. In a bowl, whisk eggs and then add milk. Add salt and pepper to taste. Stir thoroughly. Place egg mixture in a large greased baking dish. Add cooked macaroni and stir thoroughly. Add cheese chunks and again stir thoroughly so that everything is evenly distributed. Place in a 350* oven and bake for 55 min. or until the top is a golden brown. Try to let rest for 15 min. before cutting into it.

About this Recipe

  • Comments

  • 1-5 of 64
  • user
    Gayle Seidelman rodeomum - May 4, 2011
    Question, why would someone give my recipe a 1 rating, causing it to go from 5 stars to 4, without even trying to make it? This is a wonderful recipe and one that my m-i-l is known for. It's her most requested dish! :(
  • user
    Elsie Perrett twiga13 - May 4, 2011
    Hi Gayle, I just saved and rated this recipe so you are back up to 5 stars.
  • user
    Gayle Seidelman rodeomum - May 4, 2011
    Aww, thank you Elsie. I was just a lil put back by that. I would NEVER give someone's recipe a 1 star rating...even if it was really 1 star. LOL I just thought that was being a little mean.
  • user
    Mama Dee recipemama - May 4, 2011
    thanks for the recipe:)
  • user
    Mama Dee recipemama - May 4, 2011
    Mama Dee [recipemama] has shared this recipe with discussion group:
    6 and less