Better Than Arby's Beef & Cheddar

Recipe Rating:	3 Ratings4
Categories:	Beef, Other Main Dishes, Other Soups, For Kids
Keywords:	Onion, Garlic, cheese, powder, sugar, Better, Than, pepper, mix, cheddar, roast, salt, Brown, dry, dark, Water, nacho, Arby's
Prep Time:	10 Min
Cook Time:	5 Hr

Ingredients

3 - 4 lb	beef roast
1/2 c	water
1/2 c	dark brown sugar, firmly packed
2 pkg	onion soup mix, dry
1 large	onion, chopped
1/2 tsp	garlic powder
	salt & pepper, to taste
	onion rolls

Pinched by teeshaw, and 183 more.

Kimmi Knippel (Sweet_Memories)

Cooked to Perfection

Cullowhee, NC (pop. 41,052)

KimmiK

Member Since Apr 2011

Kimmi's Notes:

Love the taste of Arby's roast beef? Then you'll love this crock pot spin of the infamous roast beef.

I have never been a fan of Arby's, but I am willing to try this yummy sounding recipe....this was soooo good!

Directions

Place roast in crock pot. Stir remaining ingredients together & pour over roast. Cook on LOW 5 hours.

Serve on onion rolls. Leftovers freeze beautifully.

OPTION:

Pour cheddar cheese soup, nacho cheese or Homemade Cheese Whiz over when serving.

Comments

1-12 of 33 comments

Showing OLDEST First
(Switch to Newest First)

Kimmi Knippel... KimmiK

I shared a photo of this recipe.

Kim Cleaves KC2633

Mar 2, 2012

I'm going to have to give this one a try. My dad loved Arby's when it first came out....before they switched over to the compressed beef roll. Might be a couple of weeks but I'll let you know!

Kimmi Knippel... KimmiK

Mar 2, 2012

Ok.

Vanessa "Nikita"... Kitkat777

Vanessa "Nikita" Milare [Kitkat777] has shared this recipe with discussion groups:
Cooking Pen Pals - The Friendliest Group on JAP
E-Mail Pen Pal Recipe
Everything Cooking made Easy
Kitchen Mishaps & Bloopers: LOL
Preferred Products Past and Present
Sandwiches Only
Sandwiches, Sammiches & Sammies
Stories to Ponder

Kimmi Knippel... KimmiK

Mar 3, 2012

I just remembered a recipe that would go good on this.... Homemade Cheese Whiz from Pat Duran. Thanks again Pat!!!!

Helen Bensel ggmahelen

Mar 15, 2012

I give this a 85 plus. I made this for dinner tonight. also had party potatoes and baked beans. Horsey sauce is excellent
condiment.

Kimmi Knippel... KimmiK

Mar 16, 2012

Wow! Thank you so much!!!! Please rate, family test & vote for it!

kimmy grimes finickykitten

Apr 13, 2012

i want to try this for a sunday nascar day! quick question so i put the roast beef in the crockpot for 12 hours? then it will be done in the morning?

Helen Bensel ggmahelen

Apr 13, 2012

This recipe was very good. However, Mine was over cooked. Could not slice as it was falling apart. I will make again checking after six hours and every couple hours after that.

Helen Bensel ggmahelen

I tried this recipe and say it's Family Tested & Approved!

Kimmi Knippel... KimmiK

Apr 13, 2012

Hey another Kimmy! According to the recipe, yes, that is what it states. But after seeing Helen's response....I wonder. It's funny cause I'm actually making this tomorrow. I think maybe I'll try 6 - 8 hours & see where that leaves us. I too thought that that was a long time to keep in the crock pot, even on low.....

But Helen....falling apart is a good sign that it's tender...no? But Helen, I'm a little confused. You gave it a 85 plus, but only gave it 2 stars. Why?

kimmy grimes finickykitten

Apr 13, 2012

lol thanks for the response.. im actually going to store right now to make it for tomorrow too

1 2 3 Next