Sugar Free Low Carb Egg Nog

Jennifer Parks Recipe

By Jennifer Parks DashofSpice

5 Min
2 Hr

My family likes this more than the full calorie store bought version. All the taste without all the sugar and carbs.

pinch tips: How to Cook an Over Easy Egg


1 c
fat free half and half
1 pkg
(1 ounce package) sugar-free jell-o instant vanilla pudding powder
5 c
2% milk
1/2 c
splenda granular
3/4 tsp
freshly grated nutmeg
1/4 tsp
2 tsp
brandy or rum extract
1 tsp
vanilla extract

Directions Step-By-Step

Whisk together the half & half and pudding powder until smooth – this will be very thick.
Slowly whisk in milk until smooth.
Whisk in Splenda, nutmeg, cinnamon, and extracts.
Allow to chill for at least 2 hours. Serve with whipped cream and a sprinkling of freshly grated nutmeg.
If you would like to make it richer, you can add a half a cup of egg substitute or 2 eggs.

About this Recipe

You May Also Like:


Shirley Makekau tutuwoman
Dec 4, 2011
I will have to try this as I have always connected egg nog with Christmas time.
Sherri Williams logansw
Dec 4, 2011
thanks for this low carb version. i'm like shirley, gotta try this one for christmas. sw☺
Dec 4, 2011 - S I shared this recipe with discussion group: Let's Have a Beverage! (aka "Let's Have A Drink!")
Monqiue Baber Monqiue_Baber
Dec 7, 2012
i so happy i found this my little girl has t1d and its hard to find it she is so happy that i found this we are on our way the store right now THAL YOU SO MUCH
Ann Meyers Ann_Meyers
Nov 21, 2014
This is really quite good if you have a craving for eggnog and can't bear to "spend" 120-220 calories for 1/2 cup of the products in the store. It's better the next day, though. I blended it thoroughly with a stick blender and it helped with the clumps of cinnamon that tend not to dissolve that well in cold liquid. I also added some ground allspice and a few pinches of ground cloves. I didn't add the Egg Beaters and it was still thick enough. Incidentally, the Jello SF pudding packages are now .8 of an ounce, not 1 full ounce any longer. But it still worked just fine.