Debi's StoryI have never been a fan of this pie until a friend raised $400 on one pie at a church auction and I said ok I want that recipe and I loved it!! Not only did I like it I loved how simple it was to make which made it even more wonderful! Every year this pie sells for big bucks the church loves it too =)
all purpose flour
Find more recipes at goboldwithbutter.com
uncooked deep dish pie crust
12 c sugar
¼ c flour
21 stick butter melted
3 eggs beaten
1 tsp vanilla
1 c buttermilk
Hand mix these in separate bowl
3Then gradually add dry mixture and hand mix
Pour into deep dish pie crust
Bake at 350 60-70 minutes or until middle of pie is set
if top starts browning before its finished I always lay a piece of foil over the top once light brown then finish cooking =)
About this Recipe
Debi Newton simplysimple - Mar 6, 2012
Thank you and so glad you like it =) It really is so simple and so good I agree with ya =)
Martha Benner Marti37 - Jun 28, 2014
Have buttermilk and making this tomorrow. I lost my original recipe but this look similar. Thanks.
BEVERLY GRAY Beverlysrecipes - Oct 6, 2014
can you use margarine?
BEVERLY GRAY Beverlysrecipes - Sunday at 8:35 PM
Love, love, love this pie.