Peanut Butter Fudge Ice Cream Pie

Recipe Rating:
 3 Ratings
Serves: 8
Prep Time:


1 qt softened french vanilla ice cream
1 c chunky style peanut butter
1 pre-made chocolate or vanilla cookie crust
1/2 c salted peanuts coarsely chopped
1 c jar of hot fudge ice cream topping melted
canned or fresh whipped cream
10 small peanut butter cups
2 Tbsp caramel ice cream topping

The Cook

Laurie Lenartowicz Recipe
Well Seasoned
Livingston, TN (pop. 4,058)
Member Since Jan 2011
Laurie's notes for this recipe:
I recently bought some french vanilla ice cream to use with a Dutch Apple Pie. Since we don't like plain vanilla ice cream, I needed a way to use the leftovers. Everyone loves peanut butter and chocolate so this frozen silky treat was born.
Make it Your Way...

Personalize This


In a large bowl, soften the ice cream.
With electric mixer on low, whip in the peanut butter until well blended.
Spoon 1/2 of ice cream mixture into pie crust.
Top ice cream with 3/4 cup of the melted, cooled hot fudge. Top fudge with 1/4 cup of salted chopped peanuts.
Pour remaining ice cream into pie shell. Put remaining fudge in a plastic bag and cut off one corner. Drizzle top of pie with fudge. Drizzle caramel ice cream topping over the pie with a spoon.
Sprinkle top of pie with the remaining 1/4 cup peanuts. Cover and freeze for 2 or more hours until firm.
Decorate with whipped cream around the edges. Place peanut butter cups around the whipped cream (optional.)
When ready to serve, take pie from freezer and slice with a warm knife that's been run under hot water. Return unused portion covered to the freezer.

1-5 of 8 comments

Showing OLDEST First
(Switch to Newest First)
user Erin Briley psybri - Jul 4, 2011
My aunt used to make a pie just like this years ago and I've been looking for the recipe ever since. Can't wait to make it!
user Pat Duran kitchenchatter - Aug 22, 2011
I have a great recipe for this pie too; a Little different and it gets raves every time I make it. This recipe you posted is a lot Q & E will try it next time to see how everyone likes it- it will save me a little time. But if you want check out my recipe too "Pat's Peanut Butter Pie" Thanks for sharing your recipe. Pat/KC
user Laurie Lenartowicz llenartowicz - May 22, 2012
I shared a photo of this recipe. View photo
user Diana Harper diharper - May 31, 2012
My favorite so far, girlfriend! :)
user Terressa Kennedy rvrctygrrl - Jun 26, 2012
Woman! you are NOT playing fair here. I'm drooling just looking at it.

Gift Membership