Rose Mary Mogan


I wanted to create a VERY SPECIAL DESSERT for my husband for Father's Day to show him just how much I appreciate him. This is the dessert I came up with. I already have a Peanut Butter Pie recipe posted that he loves, so this one had to EXCEED the pie.

I made the crust using Peanut Butter cookie mix, then I added peanuts to add crunch, and Peanut Butter Chips to add extra flavor, then filled it with mini Reese's pieces, used Caramel Condensed milk & Light & Dark Brown Sugar, as well as Butterscotch Pudding to achieve that golden Caramel color. HE LOVED IT, it's his new favorite. We love it

Featured Pinch Tips Video

☆☆☆☆☆ 0 votes
12 or more depending on portion size
55 Min
1 Hr 55 Min



2 c
peanut butter cookie mix (i used betty crocker)
3 Tbsp
extra virgin olive oil (evoo)
2 Tbsp


4 pkg
cream cheese, softened 8 oz. each
11/2 c
creamy peanut butter
1/2 c
light brown sugar
2/3 c
dark brown sugar
1 can(s)
condensed milk not evaporated (caramel flavor)
1 c
chopped peanuts
1 Tbsp
vanilla bean extract
1 box
butterscotch instant pudding 3.4 oz size
1 pkg
peanut butter chips, 11 oz.
2 Tbsp
wondra flour
5 large
eggs,room temperature
1 c
sour cream


1 1/2 c
sour cream
3 Tbsp
1 tsp
each vanilla bean paste & lemon juice


snack size reeses cups cut in half
mini reeses peanut butter cups
1/4 c
reese's peanut butter dessert topping


Step 1 Direction Photo

1Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.This is most of the main ingredients used in the recipe.

Step 2 Direction Photo

2Add the crust ingredients to a small bowl and stir to blend together. Then pour into a 9 inch springform pan, and press crumb mixture evenly in the bottom and up the sides of the pan. Then place in preheated 350 degree F. oven and bake for 8- 10 minutes, Remove and set aside to cool till needed.

Step 3 Direction Photo

3Using a large mixing bowl,I used a stand mixer, add in the softened cream cheese and peanut Butter, and beat until creamy and smooth.

Step 4 Direction Photo

4Then add in both brown sugars and the condensed caramel milk, and beat until completely blended together.

Step 5 Direction Photo

5Now add in the eggs, one at a time, beating well after each has been added.

Step 6 Direction Photo

6Combine the Pudding and flour together then pour into the cream cheese peanut Butter mixture & beat until well blended.

Step 7 Direction Photo

7Dust the peanut butter chips with about one Tablespoon of flour, then pour into cream cheese batter, add in the chopped peanuts, vanilla Bean extract, & beat or stir with a large spoon, until blended together. Dusting the chips with flour prevents them from sinking to the bottom of the cheesecake during baking.

Step 8 Direction Photo

8Now you can add the 24 mini cups to the batter by stirring them in or do as I did, and push them randomly into the cheesecake batter.

Step 9 Direction Photo

9Then cover top with enough remaining batter to within an inch and a half from top of pan. NOTICE: I HAD ENOUGH REMAINING BATTER TO MAKE AN EXTRA SERVING SIZE CHEESE CAKE,WHICH BAKES IN 45 MINUTES.

Step 10 Direction Photo

10Wrap the bottom of the cheesecake pan with a triple layer of aluminum foil. Then place the cheesecake pan into a much larger pan and carefully pour boiling hot water around the base of the cheesecake, to at least 1 and a half inches deep. Note: I put the pan in the oven FIRST, BEFORE CAREFULLY ADDING THE HOT WATER.

Step 11 Direction Photo

11Bake in preheated 325 degrees F. for 1 hour and a half. Then turn off oven, open the door slightly but leave the cheesecake in oven for 15 minutes.This is the amount of batter I had before filling the pan.

Step 12 Direction Photo

12Then make the sour cream topping by combining all the ingredients in a small bowl, while the cake is in the oven. After 15 minutes, spread the sour cream topping over the top of the cake.

13Leave the cake in the oven for an additional 45 minutes with the oven still turned off. Then remove cheesecake and allow to sit at room temperature for at least 1 and a half hours before putting in the fridge.

Step 14 Direction Photo

14Now top the cake with the sprinkles and the snack size peanut butter cup, cut in half and arrange as desired.

Step 15 Direction Photo

15Refrigerate at least 6 hours or over night before serving.

Step 16 Direction Photo

16Before serving remove the sides of the spring form pan, then cut into serving size pieces. I added a chocolate syrup to a long platter then added the cheesecake slices.

Step 17 Direction Photo

17This is what the cake looked like once I removed the sides of the springform pan.

Step 18 Direction Photo

18This is what the cut cheesecake looks like.

Step 19 Direction Photo

19This is the extra serving size that I gave away. It only needed 45 minutes to bake, and I did not use a water bath for this one because of the time it needed to bake. I had not added the sour cream topping or sprinkles before I took the picture..

About this Recipe