Incredible Buttermilk Pie Recipe

No Photo

Have you made this?

 Share your own photo!

INCREDIBLE BUTTERMILK PIE

Lori Newton

By
@lokie64

This is my friend, Nancy's, recipe & she got it from her friend, Mary. I don't care for buttermilk pie, but a lot of my friends & family LOVE it. And from what everyone tells me this is the BEST buttermilk pie they ever had. I've tried several different recipes & they are never as good as this one. It's really easy, just takes time in the oven to let the center set. FYI - a professional organization I was in used to have a bake sale every year & this was the most requested pie every year.


Featured Pinch Tips Video

Rating:

Serves:

8-10

Prep:

10 Min

Cook:

1 Hr

Method:

Bake

Ingredients

1 stick
butter, softened
2 c
sugar
1 c
buttermilk
3
eggs, slightly beaten
3 Tbsp
flour
1 tsp
vanilla extract
1 dash(es)
ground nutmeg

Directions Step-By-Step

1
Cream butter and sugar together.
2
Add buttermilk and eggs to sugar mixture and mix well by hand.
3
Add flour, vanilla and nutmeg. Mix together.
4
Pour into 9 inch pie pan and bake at 350 degrees for 50-60 minutes or until center is firm. (My oven takes about 70 minutes)
5
HEALTHIER OPTIONS - Sugar can be substituted with 1 cup of Stevia OR 2 cups of Truvia Baking Blend OR 2 cups of Sugar in the Raw. Use organic whole grain pie crust or organic gluten free pie crust.
6
GLUTEN FREE VERSION - use Gluten Free pie crust & gluten free flour for filling.

About this Recipe

Course/Dish: Pies
Main Ingredient: Dairy
Regional Style: American