The Ultimate Surprise Cookie

Recipe Rating:	1 Rating5
Categories:	Cookies, Quick & Easy, For Kids, Healthy
Serves:	28-32
Prep Time:	5 Min
Cook Time:	10 Min

Ingredients

IN A MIXING BOWL ADD
1 stick	butter, softened
1/2 c	sugar
1 tsp	vanilla extract
1 1/2 tsp	lemon extract
1 large	egg
1/3 c	peanut butter
1 1/2 tsp	baking powder
1/4 tsp	salt
MIX WELL AND ADD
1 1/3 c	flour
1/3 c	rolled oats
1/4 c	sesame seeds
1/8 c	poppy seeds

Pinched by QueenJean, and 76 more.

Stormy Stewart

Well Seasoned

Mount Morris, MI (pop. 3,086)

karlyn255

Member Since Mar 2011

Stormy's Notes:

Eric named this one yesterday when I threw a bunch of stuff together and made these

Directions

Preheat oven to 350 degrees

Mix it all up and drop by spoonfuls on to a cookie sheet.

Cook 10-12 minutes and take from oven.

Cookies will be soft and so good.

Comments

1-12 of 16 comments

Showing OLDEST First
(Switch to Newest First)

Stormy Stewart karlyn255

Dec 31, 2012

for got the egg and the 1/3 cup peanut butter. am awaiting their changing it

Stormy Stewart karlyn255

Stormy Stewart [karlyn255] has shared this recipe with discussion groups:
USA State Recipes
A HALLOWEEN/SAMHAIN TRADITION
Amish Cooking
Gifts from a Jar
Gifts from the Pantry
Magic in the Kitchen
NUTS IN THE HOUSE
Tea with Laura
The Coffee Monkey

CinStraw's Kitchen CinStraw

Dec 31, 2012

don't you just love happy surprises...=;D

Kerry Clouser Kerrymc

Dec 31, 2012

Wonder how this would be without the seeds? I can't eat them. Do you have a nother idea of something to put in them?

CinStraw's Kitchen CinStraw

Dec 31, 2012

Use fresh cracked pepper.

Kerry Clouser Kerrymc

Jan 1, 2013

I hate to sound picky, but I hate pepper. Good idea for my hubby, thanks Cin

Stormy Stewart karlyn255

Jan 1, 2013

Kerry my advice is pass this one up. the seeds with the lemon is what makes it. the oatmeal gives it a little chewing ability and the peanut butter is a faint wow that is that.

Kerry Clouser Kerrymc

Jan 1, 2013

Stormy, it just sounds so good! Just can't have the seeds. Bummer

Stormy Stewart karlyn255

Jan 1, 2013

thanks, and sorry

Jaded spoon Jaded_spoon

Jan 2, 2013

Kerry...

what about adding shredded coconut instead of the seeds, or maybe some crushed nuts to add the teture of the seeds... the taste will be mildly different but not too much....

Stormy Stewart karlyn255