Creamsicle Cake

Recipe Rating:	21 Ratings5
Categories:	Cakes, Quick & Easy

Ingredients

1 pkg	orange supreme cake mix
1 pkg	orange gelatin
1/2 c	boiling water
1/2 c	cold water
TOPPING INGREDIENTS
1 small	frozen whipped topping, thawed
1 1/2 c	milk
1 small	instant vanilla pudding mix, unprepared
	orange flavoring

Pinched by Puce1, and 4,695 more.

Pam Martin-Allen

Well Seasoned

medina, TN (pop. 3,479)

sweetp

Member Since Dec 2009

Comments from the Test Kitchen:

This cake brings back so many childhood memories for me. I always loved Creamsicles and this recipe duplicates that same special flavor. You won't have any leftovers of this one...

Directions

Mix cake as directed on box for 9x13" pan. Cool.

Punch holes with meat fork. Mix jello with boiling water and cold water and pour over cake. Refrigerate cake for 1 hour to set.

TOPPING: Mix pudding with milk. Add a few drops of orange flavoring to taste.

Then fold in cool whip.

Frost as thick as you like and keep refrigerated.

Comments

1-12 of 52 comments

Showing OLDEST First
(Switch to Newest First)

jeffrey emison jeff

Dec 22, 2009

this is a wonderful cake

Christie LaRoche lilluvin

Jan 18, 2010

Having a birthday party for my sister on Friday. Told her about this cake, and it is the one she requested! Have made many poke n pour cakes, but not one of this flavor. Will let you know how well it is liked. Thanks for sharing your recipe.

Mikki Miller littledahl12

Feb 8, 2010

I made this cake yesterday. It is a deliciously moist and tasty cake. We are really enjoying it.

Telisia Dodd Mstexas1

May 12, 2010

I love always loved creamsicle, si I can't wait to try this recipe.

Alana McRae bearyliciouscakes

May 16, 2010

I'm glad I came across this receipe. I was just thinking about this past week that i wished I could find a receipe for a dreamsicle flavored cake and I think I found it can,t wait to try it! Thanks

Stephanie... SuzyBarber

May 17, 2010

I can't find orange cake mix here in Colorado - can someone give me the brand?

Dana Kruckenberg Pinkladydana

May 17, 2010

We do one layer witgh green jello and one layer with red, then frost with Coolwhip, for Christmas!!

Dianne Gilbert johnsNi9

May 19, 2010

Stephanie, Duncan Hines makes an orange cake mix. If you can't find one, you may try to add little orange flavoring and food coloring to a white or yellow cake mix.

Lori Beaumont luvnfrmoven

May 21, 2010

If you can't find orange cake mix, replace the water in the a box or plain white cake with orange juice. If you want a stronger orange flavor use undiluted concentrate.